Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter Rex's avatar

What a refreshing article in the middle of what increasingly resembles a witch hunt.

I use ChatGPT and Claude daily, and after spending enough time with both, I can often recognise their fingerprints in a text. But recognising something is not the same as condemning it. I simply make a mental note and continue reading. The judgement comes afterwards: Was it interesting? Was it well written? Did it make me think? Was it worth my time?

I once received a comment on one of my Substack articles consisting of little more than a Pangram verdict: 72% AI-written. My response was simple: Pangram was wrong. The article was 100% AI-written. Had the commenter actually read it, they would have found my disclosure at the end. And had they read my commenting rules, they would have known that I don't welcome Pangram scores. I don't give a damn about them.

That little exchange illustrates something rather sad about the current atmosphere. People are increasingly reading to catch the writer rather than to enjoy, understand, or challenge what has been written.

And the double standard is remarkable. Publishers, platforms, and editors are integrating AI into their workflows, while individual authors are expected to defend their creative integrity against statistical guesses dressed up as scientific verdicts.

AI hasn't invented bad writing, plagiarism, lazy editing, or dishonesty. Those were flourishing long before the first language model appeared. It has introduced new problems and amplified some old ones, certainly. But those problems deserve thoughtful discussion, not public trials by algorithm.

I particularly appreciate your recognition that AI-minimal, AI-assisted, and AI-integrated approaches can all be legitimate. The responsibility for the finished work remains with the person who chooses to put their name beneath it.

Perhaps we could return to a rather old-fashioned idea: read the work, judge its merits, and hold its author accountable for what it says, not for which tools may have helped produce it.

Thank you for bringing some much-needed reason and humanity into this discussion.

Pauline Baird Jones's avatar

Excellent summary of the problem. Funny how is always the authors who get the torches and pitch forks. This is very similar to how early ebook authors were treated. Though this is that treatment on steroids.

20 more comments...

Ready for more?